Tuesday, May 14, 2013

Left Turns

Let's talk a bit about left turns (this conversation assumes drive-on-the-right traffic flow). On two-way streets. Across traffic. They are undeniably dangerous. How to treat them? I think they should be broken in to four categories:
1) one lane of traffic in each direction, slow moving cars (<25 mph), not a high traffic density
2) one lane of traffic in each direction, faster cars and higher traffic density
3) two lanes of traffic (or more? how are you even biking on this street?) in each direction
4) two lanes of traffic in each direction, high traffic density

I would say that only in case (1) should you turn left at a green light across traffic without hesitation. That is to say, you'd turn left as if you were driving a car. I do this many times every day. If a car is oncoming I make sure they are also turning left before proceeding.

In all of the other cases, I don't do what I would in a car, I do what I would if I were a pedestrian. I go across the green light, going straight, as if I were not going to turn left. Then I stop at the corner or hop up on the sidewalk *slowly*, watching out for bikes and ped(estrians)s. (That's a nice word, estrian if it were a word, which it seems not to be). Then I look left and wait for that light to turn green and proceed on the street with traffic or slowly through the painted lines in the crosswalk, and proceed on my way. Hey Presto! A left turn.

What is the alternative in cases 2-4? It is to merge left into the fast moving traffic, signalling with an outstretched arm, and then turn left at the green light while moving at speed. This can work very elegantly, but it is not tolerant to error. That is to say, if you should have to slow down rapidly, if the traffic is moving to fast for you to find a break, if you should fall, if a driver (now on your right) should not notice you and merge left you are in serious trouble. And this method is barely faster than the stop and turn method in the previous paragraph.

What's my point? My point is that I see too many people doing the left turn across traffic at a green light in situations 2-4. I've done it myself. But I wish our standards of behavior were a bit different, and I wish infrastructure would support the stop and turn method. This would mean a "hop up on the curb and turn left" set of ramps on corners, or a simple, painted hook left turn system of paint like this:
http://www.theurbancountry.com/2010/11/safe-left-turns-for-bicycles.html.

Has there been discussion of such a system for left turns in Seattle? I'm not aware of it, but am probably missing it.

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

Case Study: Anacortes and the San Juans (WA state)

First case study close to home, and in a market we're considering serving soon.

Start with Anacortes, where you catch the ferry for the islands. Visitors might rent bikes here and bring them on the ferry, or rent them on the islands directly.

These folks in Mt Vernon have got it right, doing $40 per day, $75 for 3 days to 1 week and offering pickup and delivery. Only downsides are they aren't located in Anacortes near the ferry and they only operate may through september. But this market may be more highly seasonal than Seattle. They are renting comfort bikes, Treks it looks like, which will make many people happy except for bikers, but these are an excellent choice to suit a wide variety of people.
http://www.countrycycling.com/Bike%20Rentals.html

In Anacortes Skagit bike center keeps coming up but I can't find any rentals on their site and the direct link to the rentals gives a "not found". But part of the site is working, tough to figure out what's up here:
http://skagitcyclecenter.com/articles/bike-rental-reservation-form-pg479.htm
The day is $40/$60 and the week is $160/$240 for a good/better bike. Their "better" bike is around $600, so that would be competitive to what SMBR offers. They charge 3x more than we do for that bike, an extra $160 per week.

In Friday Harbor we've got Island Cycles at $175 per week for a hybrid similar to the SMBR offer, $40 per day. They are also offering mid-range and higher-end road bikes and correspondingly higher prices.

Lopez Island is a terrific place to bike, and seems to get more than its fair share of bike tourists judging by my one summer visit there. There, Lopez Bicycle Works is doing $30 per day, $130 per week rentals. This is getting closer to what SMBR would offer, and these prices seem accessible enough that they likely get their share of longer term renters. Village Cycles, which is apparently for sale, is doing the same rates. Lopez is a rarely competitive and relatively well-priced area for bike rentals.

On Orcas we've got Wildlife Cycles at $35 per day and $115 per week. Again, the prices here are surprisingly good. More demand equals lower prices?

That covers it, daily rentals at $35-$60 and weekly at $115 - $240. Anacortes for some reason is a bit less competitive than some of the islands, but a detour to Mt. Vernon could be worth it for the budget-minded. Getting closer to big European city pricing here, but none of these are competitive by international standards.




Sunday, April 14, 2013

Case Study: Paris

Paris is famous for its city-sponsored bike-share program, Velib. Prices are $2.20 for a day-use pass and  $10 for a weekly pass that allows unlimited rides of 30 minutes or less. Additional half hours are $1.30. This is a completely different range of prices from standard bike rental, even by Copenhagen standards. Even if your ride each way every day takes an hour (or, say, 40 minutes, which is quite plausible) you're still looking at a mere $17.50 in overage charge and $10 base charge, or $27.50 for a week of bike commuting both ways. This is super cheap by any standard.

For those who are not familiar with bike-share, this is a terrific system for casual biking and tourism but it is not for everyone. In particular the bikes are typically heavy, they are not a standard hybrid bike with many gears, so they offer a lesser biking experience and are only comfortable for shorter rides. The system also requires that you drop off the bike at another bike share station -- if you are staying at a hotel and your work destination does not have a share station nearby, this makes bike share close to useless. So depends on your particular destination. Bike share is fundamentally a different product from standard daily or long-term bike rental, and it is terrific for casual sight-seeing and short commuter rides where share stations are close by. For longer rides or most commutes it is not very practical.

Two other important notes of a more practical bent. Velib is subsidized by advertising and a slight public subsidy-- it is more like a subway or bus or other public transportation than it is like car rental or standard daily bike rental. (The public subsidy issue here is complex and debatable -- short version bikes get broken and stole and the city has to pay to replace them). Also, with Velib the bikes are not guaranteed to be present, or working (a backwards seat indicates a broken bike) at every station. So your travel plans might be disturbed, especially on a nice day, when you don't find a bike present. Not a problem for casual sightseeing, otherwise its an issue. The NY Times story on this is illuminating: http://www.nytimes.com/2008/07/13/world/europe/13paris.html?pagewanted=all

The most prominent standard bike rental is fat tire bike rentals, at 25 euros per day 100 per week -- $32 per day and $130 per week. The bikes are not hybrids, but beach cruiser style bikes, these are not a great option for getting around by bike over longer distances, great and fun (although not my first choice) for cruising around and tourism.

Looks like other shops are renting more standard hybrid bikes with more gears and better (lighter) frames from 15 euros per day, or about $20. After lots of digging you can find an example online, maybe their SEO doesn't work for english? An example would be:
 http://www.parisvelosympa.com 
Which is charging 20 euros per day + 10 each extra day -- that's $26 plus $13 extra per day, putting a week at $104. They are renting city bikes and basic mountain bikes, that look much more comfortable and easy to ride than the Velib offers. None of these shops is offering an online reservation system, although it seems they have enough capacity to ensure rentals most times.



Saturday, March 23, 2013

Cold weather and bike reservations


I was inspired by Tom at Seattle Bike Blog's analysis of the fremont bridge bike frequency dataset to look at my own web traffic data for SMBR. Also inspired by the fact that it snowed yesterday, and that cold weather made a very clear showing in website traffic. Above I've displayed the (normalized) daily site visits in red and the daily temperature high (in degrees F) in blue for the last month 2/22 to 3/22.

The results were slightly surprising -- I had thought that some of those weird spikes, like the drop on 3/12, were due to cold weather. But that one, for example, was not due to a cold day. But the decline in traffic 3/21 and 3/22 is clearly due to declining temperature (and rain, which for some reason almanac.com was always placing at precip = 0 even though my memory tells me that that wasn't true. Need a better historical weather data source). The most clear finding looks like temperature swings are significant and my traffic model is like this -- there's some baseline level of traffic, but a much warmer day bumps it up and a much colder day bumps it down. Smaller temperature changes have no effect.

I hypothesized that website views are sensitive to change in temperature, not just temperature -- if it was 50 one day and then 56, folks suddenly start thinking about biking. So I made that plot (the first day doesn't have data because the n-1 point doesn't exist in this dataset). Here, at least in the later March data, I'm seeing a small day-shift in web traffic. A down-trend in weather forecasts a decrease in web traffic the next day, but only if that temperature decrease is sizeable. I'll be able to prepare more data like this when traffic picks up even more. Of course weather variability will decrease in the summer, so the temperature delta data won't be super interesting.

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Case Study: Copenhagen

To understand the global bike rental market I'm going to start doing some case studies, beginning with Europe, because the market there is drastically different. Almost unintelligible to an American, really. Copenhagen and Amsterdam are the most bike friendly cities I've visited, both places where I rented a bike for some or all of my stay and didn't even think anything of it (at the time it didn't occur to me to ask why these affordable and convenient bike rental services don't exist in the US).

There are a few shops with upwards of a hundred bikes that show up in a google search, Baisikeli and cycleborsen are two of the top three (the third is Baisikeli with a different website). Prices start at $13 for a single day rental of a 24-speed bike. Thirteen US dollars. The cheapest rental in Seattle is $30, while a conveniently located one is $45.

I'll do a little table (doing a multi-gear bike in good shape, Baisikeli offers lower-end bikes that seem a bit risky, but are even cheaper):

Shop             Day Week   Month
Baisikeli       $19    $66     $139
cycleborsen   $13   $60     $138
Luca's            $8     ?         ?

These prices use currency conversion from xe.com on today's date 20130319.

Just to make this clear, a downtown Seattle rental shop charges $10 for one hour, $45 for a day, $175 for 5 days  -- lets say you could somehow finagle a week for $220. The day costs roughly 3 (2.3 to 3.5) times more than a day's bike rental in Copenhagen. The weekly rental in Seattle is more expensive than a month in Copenhagen -- it is roughly 3.3 times more expensive in Seattle.

Let's dispose of the first, most obvious explanation -- is Seattle somehow 3 times more expensive of a place to do business? No. Turns out consumer prices are 23% higher in general in Copenhagen (http://www.numbeo.com/cost-of-living/compare_cities.jsp?country1=United+States&city1=Seattle%2C+WA&country2=Denmark&city2=Copenhagen). This effect is opposite the observed price. Just to make this clear, a combo meal is about $12 in Copenhagen at McDonald's and $7 in Seattle.

As for other features of the rental experience, it looks like cycleborsen offers free bike delivery, while Baisikeli only does so for larger groups. A lock is generally included and it looks like a helmet is a slight extra fee (but note that in Denmark most people bike without a helmet, because of their good bike paths separated from cars, and their bicycle injury and fatality rates are actually lower than in the US). Cycleborsen's website is in Danish, and generally less user friendly, but neither one is a very modern website. From looking at the bikes these are slightly less good bikes than what you would get with a hybrid bike rental in Seattle for $45 (or from SMBR). The Baisikeli bikes mostly have 7 speeds, heavier frames, and coaster brakes (pedal backwards to stop). It looks like you would have to pay a bit more to get a better bike like what you would rent in Seattle, or from us. Judging by Yelp, an admittedly poor metric, it sounds like the renter experience is good at Baisikeli, so these are not low-quality enterprises.

One other note, the one biggest website, Baisikeli, is a not-for-profit. They rent standard and budget bikes and move bikes out to shops in Africa where they are donated to those in need of transportation. So they are not an incredibly profitable business, but they are certainly economically sustainable. The other shops seem to be for-profit businesses.

This copenhagen case study shows that bike rentals at $60-$70 per week are sustainable in a city with higher costs, especially labor cost (Denmark doesn't have a formal minimal wage, but $15 per hour is the minimum paid by most cleaning companies, so low end labor costs are very high by US standards). This should be possible in the US at the same rate -- and realistically, given a discount in labor cost and real estate in Seattle vs Copenhagen the prices should be more like 30% lower in the US. If a big mac meal is 40% cheaper here, why not a bike rental? It is very likely that insurance costs are higher here than in Denmark, so that may account for some of the difference, but without knowing the details of the Danish insurance market I can guarantee that that effect is likely less than 20% of the price difference.

Saturday, January 5, 2013

Winter Biking

Having moved from Boston to Seattle, winter here seems fairly mild by comparison, and I consider winter to be a great time to bike. Since I tend to get a bit sweaty in the summer, even on a mild 70-degree day, the main advantage of winter biking is comfort and the fact that I can get where I'm going without having to bring a shirt to change into. The downside would be that its more likely to be raining and dark.
So considering the winter biking essentials, I'd say they are:
1) Front LED lights with a bit of range, although in the city it doesn't have to project too far as you're rarely in the absolute dark. I once got stuck on a country road, on a road bike, in the middle of the forest, in absolute darkness; it wasn't even possible to take a step forward and see where your foot would fall. Had to sit by the side of the road until a local bus came by.
2) Rear LED light
3) waterproof jacket, although doesn't have to be particularly fancy, could be a rain-slicker style rubberized cloth
4) mid-weight windproof gloves. I love the ones from seirus. Too thin and woven means wind will penetrate. Too thick and your hands will get sweaty.
5) A thin beany for under the helmet. This can make all the difference in heat retention.

End of list. No need for special insulating top or waterproof bottoms most of the time. As I do all year round if its raining I'll bring an extra pair of slacks or jeans (depending on the outfit) to change into if my pants get wet.

This all raises the question, from a practical and business point of view, why don't more people bike in the winter? It seems to be a combination of lacking good gear -- although most people who have ski gear probably are fine, just need thinner gloves -- and lacking experience in winter biking, having only gone on balmy days. To get around this then requires a bit of gear, the gloves mostly, and someone pointing out that, hey, it might be easy and fun to bike year round.

The last question is how to put this into practice at SMBR. Many ski resorts will rent a jacket, gloves, helmet, pants, goggles, etc. Should we offer a winter package, say with a jacket and gloves and a thin biking hat for a small fee?

Saturday, December 1, 2012

Phone reservations are difficult and not worth it.

I have had a number of people reserve by phone. Every one of those people has cancelled or simply failed to follow up and de facto cancelled without alerting me.
My hypothesis is that the web site is clear and understandable, the product is simple and well-explained.  People who see the product and decide they want a bike just reserve using the online system / email. Done. prob (purchase) = 1.
People who see the product and are unsure have to call to better understand what we're doing, or to help assuage the uncertainty. Perhaps they need a harder "sell"? In any event, they have a prob(purchase) < 1, so far prob (purchase) = 0, with a small sample size. So I'll say they have 0 < prob (purchase) < 1, with sample size of 4 (I think the central limit theorem would fail here, so hard to estimate the true confidence).
These considerations lead me to believe that phone reservations are unlikely to result in a sale, and they are more costly in terms to time, so the expected value of phone reservations is very low. Lets say the prob (purchase) = 0.5 and the cost of the phone work is $20.
Then EV = 0.5 * 80 - 20 = $20.
Just not worth it.
On the other hand an online sale requires so work up front and has prob(purchase) = 0.9 after the reservation is booked.
EV = 0.9 * 80 = $72.
That's why I've discouraged them in the future, placing the phone number in a somewhat difficult to find place and only allowing email or online reservations.